SFDR 2.0: EU Strikes Deal on New Sustainable Investment Product Categories
Lawmakers in the European Parliament and EU Member States announced that they have reached a deal on a major revamp of the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR), the EU’s key legislation setting out how financial market participants have to disclose sustainability information for their investment products.
One of the most significant changes to the regulation is the creation of three new categories for financial products making ESG claims, with the negotiations between lawmakers and member states hinging largely on the treatment of fossil fuel companies in the new “Transition” category.
The Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation, in application since 2021, sets out how financial market participants, such as asset managers, have to communicate sustainability information to investors, regarding the integration of sustainability risks and the consideration of adverse sustainability impacts in their processes and the provision of sustainability‐related information with respect to financial products.
A 2023 review of the SFDR framework by the European Commission revealed that the current requirements of the regulation include disclosures that are too long and complex, making it difficult for investors to understand and compare the environmental or social characteristics of financial products. Among the key concerns noted by the Commission was the apparent mis-use of the regulation’s Article 8 and Article 9 disclosure regime as de-facto sustainability labels, which it said may have led investors to believe that Article 9 funds are necessarily fully sustainable and that Article 8 funds strongly integrate ESG factors, even though this is not necessarily the case, increasing the risk of greenwashing.
To address these concerns, the Commission proposed introducing a new simplified categorization system for financial products making ESG claims, based on three recommended categories, including “Sustainable,” for products contributing to sustainability goals, such as climate, environment or social goals, that already meet high sustainability standards; “Transition,” for products investing in companies and projects that are not yet sustainable, but that are on a credible transition path, or contribute toward improvements in areas such as climate, environment or social areas, and; “ESG Basics,” for products that do not meet the Sustainable or Transition criteria, but integrate ESG investment approaches, such as those focused on best-in-class performers on a given ESG metric, or those excluding the worst ESG performers.
The Commission’s proposal set out a series of criteria for each category including exclusions, or industries and activities in which the product would not be able to invest, and positive contribution, with a requirement for at least 70% of the portfolio to follow an ESG strategy that matches product’s category.
The Commission also proposed that both the Sustainable and Transition categories would exclude companies expanding their fossil fuel activities, although both the European Council of member states and Parliament adopted negotiating positions that would allow for the inclusion of companies expanding fossil fuel under certain conditions.
Council’s position replaced the Commission’s fossil fuel exclusion in the Transition with a requirement for companies active in the fossil fuel sector to allocate 20% of their capital expenditure to economic activities aligned with the EU Taxonomy, and to have a clear, time-bound strategy to reduce Scope 1 and 2 greenhouse gas emissions.
Parliament’s position similarly inserted a 20% Taxonomy-aligned capex requirement, while adding a more stringent requirement for companies to put more capital into sustainable activities than into new fossil fuel projects.
The agreement reached on Thursday appears to include a compromise between the parties, with the Transition requirements allowing the inclusion of companies expanding their fossil fuel activities, provided that they have a clear, time-bound strategy to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, aligned with the Paris agreement, and allocate 20% of their capital expenditure to economic activities aligned with the EU Taxonomy, and an additional condition that they increase the share of capital expenditure for EU Taxonomy-related activities over time.
Sustainable finance and investment groups criticized the inclusion of fossil fuel companies, with Isabella Ritter, Senior EU Policy Officer at ShareAction, saying that the move “risks turning the Transition category into a safe haven for fossil fuel companies.”
Ritter added:
“A transition category should support companies moving away from fossil fuels, not allow their expansion to continue. This risks undermining the credibility and coherence of the entire framework from day one.”
Other key aspects of the revamped SFDR include a requirement for products qualifying for the Sustainable or Transition categories to identify and disclose the Principle Adverse Impacts (PAI) of their investments, outlining the negative effects they may have on the environment and society, with Transition category products required to include fossil fuel use and GHG emissions among the PAI indicators.
The agreement also eliminates an exclusion of general purpose issuances by EU-based public sector bodies from the Transition category, under certain conditions. The EU Council noted that established framework of climate and sustainability commitments at EU level make it possible to assess compatibility of these securities with sustainability objectives, and that the inclusion of these securities would significantly expand the ability of insurance and pension fund investors to invest in Transition category funds.
Additionally, the agreement allows financial market participants to choose not to apply the categorization system to alternative investment funds offered exclusively to professional investors, while including safeguards to ensure that retail investors do not indirectly find themselves in possession of such products.
The provisional agreement still requires endorsement by the Parliament and Council, with the new rules set to apply two years after publication in the EU’s official journal.



